THE ORIGINS AND TEACHINGS OF ISLAM
Stes de Necker
With due acknowledgement to D.M. Murdock/Acharya S
Introduction
The Islamic World is no longer somewhere
else.
Today it is as real as humanity itself and the western world has become part
of the Islamic world.
Islam is
the fastest-growing major religion in Europe.
Since the
1960s, immigrants from Muslim countries started to appear in numbers in Western Europe, especially in Germany, France and Belgium.
Although large Muslim communities existed on the continent long before this,
especially in the Balkans, this was the first major wave of
immigration of Muslims to north-western.
Muslims in Europe are not a homogeneous group. They are
of various national, ethnic and racial identities. The top countries of origin
of Muslims in Western Europe are Pakistan, Turkey and the Maghreb countries (Morocco, Algeria,Tunisia).
Muslims
also vary in terms of their religious commitment: some adhere very strictly to
the tenets of Islam while others have largely assimilated into secular European
culture.
In Western
Europe, Muslims generally live in major urban areas, often concentrated in poor
neighbourhoods of large cities.
According to
the Pew Forum, the total number of Muslims in Europe in 2010 was
about 44 million (6%). The total number of Muslims in the European Union in 2010 was about 19 million
(3.8%). The French capital of Paris and its metropolitan area has the largest number (up to 1.7
million according to The Economist) of Muslims than any
other city in the European Union.
London also has a substantial community of Muslim origin,
numbering about 1 million within the limits of Greater London and exceeding this figure when the entire
metropolitan area is taken into account.
If the
current rate of migration of Muslims to Europe and the Muslim fertility rate
remains constant, by 2030, people of Muslim faith or origin are predicted to
form about 10% of the French population and 8% of the European population.
The table
below lists large cities of the European Union with significant Muslim
populations.
City
|
Country
|
%
Muslim (est.)
|
Amsterdam
|
Netherlands
|
14%
- Bureau voor Onderzoek en Statistiek: 'Geloven in Amsterdam' [Bureau of
Research and Statistics: Faith in Amsterdam] (PDF).
Retrieved 25 April 2012.
|
Antwerp
|
Belgium
|
|
Berlin
|
Germany
|
6% - Daun, Holger (2004). Educational
strategies among Muslims in the context of globalization : some national
case studies
9% - Islam in Berlin". Euro-Islam.info. Retrieved 3 January 2013.
|
Birmingham
|
UK
|
14.3% - When town halls turn to Mecca". The Economist. 4 December
15% - Nydell, Margaret K. Understanding Arabs: a
contemporary guide to Arab society. Boston, MA: Intercultural Press.
p. 132. ISBN 9780983955801.
In
2011 they constituted 25 percent of Rotterdam, Marseilles, and Amsterdam; 20%
of Malmo; 15 percent of Brussels and Birmingham; and 10 percent of London,
Paris, Copenhagen, and Vienna.
Muslims
in Western Europe originate from both Arab and non-Arab countries. Those in
the United Kingdom are primarily from South Asia, in France from North and
West Africa, in Germany from Turkey, in Belgium from Morocco, and in the
Netherlands from Morocco and Turkey.
26.9% - 2011 Census: Religion, local authorities in England and Wales". United
Kingdom Census 2011. Office for National Statistics. Retrieved 12
December 2012.
|
Blackburn
|
UK
|
28.4% - 2011 Census: Religion, local authorities in England and Wales". United
Kingdom Census 2011. Office for National Statistics. Retrieved 12
December 2012
|
Bradford
|
UK
|
15% - Micklethwait, John;
Wooldridge, Adrian (2009). God is back how the global revival of faith is changing
the world. New York: Penguin Press.ISBN 9781101032411.
Muslims
are highly concentrated—they make up 24 percent of the population in
Amsterdam; 20 percent in Malmo and Marseille; 15 percent in Paris, Brussels,
Bradford, and Birmingham; and 10 percent or more in London and Copenhagen.
32.4% - 2011 Census: Religion, local authorities in England and Wales". United
Kingdom Census 2011. Office for National Statistics. Retrieved 12
December 2012.
|
Brussels
|
Belgium
|
15% - Nydell, Margaret K. Understanding
Arabs: a contemporary guide to Arab society. Boston, MA: Intercultural Press.
p. 132. ISBN 9780983955801.
In
2011 they constituted 25 percent of Rotterdam, Marseilles, and Amsterdam; 20%
of Malmo; 15 percent of Brussels and Birmingham; and 10 percent of London,
Paris, Copenhagen, and Vienna.
Muslims
in Western Europe originate from both Arab and non-Arab countries. Those in
the United Kingdom are primarily from South Asia, in France from North and
West Africa, in Germany from Turkey, in Belgium from Morocco, and in the
Netherlands from Morocco and Turkey.
17% - When town halls turn to Mecca". The Economist. 4 December 2008. Retrieved 28 January 2013.
25.5% - Jan Hertogen, "In België wonen 628.751
moslims(*), 6,0% van de bevolking. In Brussel is dit 25,5%, in Wallonië 4,0%,
in Vlaanderen 3,9%," BuG 100 - Bericht uit het Gewisse -
11-09-2008, www.npdata.be, (*)Berekend aantal - indicatief cijfer, zie
methodologie hieronder
|
Cologne
|
Germany
|
12% - Der Spiegel: "Dialog mit Außerirdischen", 25 March 2008,
retrieved 20 April 2013
|
Copenhagen
|
Denmark
|
7% - Nydell, Margaret K. Understanding
Arabs: a contemporary guide to Arab society. Boston, MA: Intercultural Press.
p. 132. ISBN 9780983955801.
In
2011 they constituted 25 percent of Rotterdam, Marseilles, and Amsterdam; 20%
of Malmo; 15 percent of Brussels and Birmingham; and 10 percent of London,
Paris, Copenhagen, and Vienna.
Muslims
in Western Europe originate from both Arab and non-Arab countries. Those in
the United Kingdom are primarily from South Asia, in France from North and
West Africa, in Germany from Turkey, in Belgium from Morocco, and in the
Netherlands from Morocco and Turkey.
|
Frankfurt
|
Germany
|
11.8% - Schröpfer, Waltraud (2007) Frankfurter Statistische
Berichte "Muslime in Frankfurt am Main - Ergebnisse einer Schätzung",
p. 206, April 2007, retrieved 27 March 2014
|
Haskovo
|
Bulgaria
|
20% est.
|
Leicester
|
UK
|
18.6% - 2011 Census: Religion, local
authorities in England and Wales". United Kingdom Census
2011. Office for National Statistics. Retrieved 12 December 2012.
|
London
|
UK
|
8.3%, - Census 2001 profiles: London". Office for National
Statistics. Retrieved 2010-01-09.
8.5%, - When town halls turn to Mecca". The Economist. 4 December 2008. Retrieved 28 January 2013.
10%, - Micklethwait, John; Wooldridge,
Adrian (2009). God is back how the global revival
of faith is changing the world. New York: Penguin Press.ISBN 9781101032411. Muslims
are highly concentrated—they make up 24 percent of the population in
Amsterdam; 20 percent in Malmo and Marseille; 15 percent in Paris, Brussels,
Bradford, and Birmingham; and 10 percent or more in London and Copenhagen.
13.1% - 2011 Census: Religion, local authorities in England and Wales". United
Kingdom Census 2011. Office for National Statistics. Retrieved 12
December 2012.
|
Luton
|
UK
|
24.6% - Religion breakdown". National Statistics Office.
Retrieved 2013-02-20.
|
Malmö
|
Sweden
|
20% est
|
Manchester
|
UK
|
15.8% - 2011
Census: Religion, local authorities in England and Wales". United
Kingdom Census 2011. Office for National Statistics. Retrieved 12
December 2012.
|
Marseille
|
France
|
20%, - When town halls turn to
Mecca". The Economist. 4 December 2008. Retrieved 28 January 2013.
25%, - Being Muslim in France" (PDF). Brookings Institution.
p. 22. Retrieved 16 February 2013.
35% - Erlanger, Steven (27 December 2009). "French Mosque’s Symbolism Varies With Beholder". New York Times. Retrieved 14 October 2012. France’s
second-largest city, which is at least 35 percent Muslim
|
Milan
|
Italy
|
7% - 10%
|
Paris
|
France
|
10%, - Nydell, Margaret K. Understanding
Arabs: a contemporary guide to Arab society. Boston, MA: Intercultural Press.
p. 132. ISBN 9780983955801.
In
2011 they constituted 25 percent of Rotterdam, Marseilles, and Amsterdam; 20%
of Malmo; 15 percent of Brussels and Birmingham; and 10 percent of London,
Paris, Copenhagen, and Vienna.
Muslims
in Western Europe originate from both Arab and non-Arab countries. Those in
the United Kingdom are primarily from South Asia, in France from North and
West Africa, in Germany from Turkey, in Belgium from Morocco, and in the
Netherlands from Morocco and Turkey.
15% - When town halls turn to
Mecca". The Economist. 4 December 2008. Retrieved 28 January 2013.
|
Rotterdam
|
Netherlands
|
13% - When town halls turn to Mecca". The Economist. 4 December 2008. Retrieved 28 January 2013.
25% - Nydell, Margaret K. Understanding Arabs: a
contemporary guide to Arab society. Boston, MA: Intercultural Press.
p. 132. ISBN 9780983955801.
In
2011 they constituted 25 percent of Rotterdam, Marseilles, and Amsterdam; 20%
of Malmo; 15 percent of Brussels and Birmingham; and 10 percent of London,
Paris, Copenhagen, and Vienna.
Muslims
in Western Europe originate from both Arab and non-Arab countries. Those in
the United Kingdom are primarily from South Asia, in France from North and
West Africa, in Germany from Turkey, in Belgium from Morocco, and in the
Netherlands from Morocco and Turkey.
|
Roubaix
|
France
|
20% - A French Town Bridges the Gap Between Muslims and Non-Muslims".
New York Times. Retrieved5 August 2013.
|
Slough
|
UK
|
23.3% - 2011 Census: Religion, local
authorities in England and Wales". United Kingdom Census
2011. Office for National Statistics. Retrieved 12 December 2012.
|
Stockholm
|
Sweden
|
20% est.
|
The Hague
|
Netherlands
|
14.2% est.
|
Utrecht
|
Netherlands
|
13.2% est.
|
Vienna
|
Austria
|
8% - When town halls turn to Mecca". The Economist. 4 December 2008. Retrieved 28 January 2013.
10% - Nydell, Margaret K. Understanding Arabs: a
contemporary guide to Arab society. Boston, MA: Intercultural Press.
p. 132. ISBN 9780983955801.
In
2011 they constituted 25 percent of Rotterdam, Marseilles, and Amsterdam; 20%
of Malmo; 15 percent of Brussels and Birmingham; and 10 percent of London,
Paris, Copenhagen, and Vienna.
Muslims in Western Europe originate from both Arab and non-Arab countries. Those in the United Kingdom are primarily from South Asia, in France from North and West Africa, in Germany from Turkey, in Belgium from Morocco, and in the Netherlands from Morocco and Turkey. |
The Real Issue
The Qur'an tells us: "not to make friendship with Jews and Christians" (5:51), "kill the disbelievers wherever we find them" (2:191), "murder them and treat them harshly" (9:123), "fight and slay the Pagans, seize them, beleaguer them, and lie in wait for them in every stratagem" (9:5). The Qur'an demands that we fight the unbelievers, and promises "If there are twenty amongst you, you will vanquish two hundred: if a hundred, you will vanquish a thousand of them" (8:65).
Since Islam is one of the world's fastest
growing religions, through conversion but mostly through reproduction, there is
a tremendous need to address this subject, which, because of crazed Islamic
fanatics, strikes fear in the hearts of many non-Muslims. Competing
with Christianity, with some 270 million people dead in its name Islam represents one
of the bloodiest and most repressive ideologies that humankind has yet
come up with.
This subject is highly important not only
because of Islam's expansion and the coming together of its leaders from around
the world, but also because certain Muslim leaders, anxious to rectify
Islam's bad rep, are making statements such as, "There are 1.8 billion
Muslims in the world, and 99.9% are peace-loving" (Haitham Bundakji).
Were this statement true, it would be both frightening in
its enormity and reassuring in its docility.
However, Islamic doctrine is
anything but "peace-loving," as it constantly calls for the slaying
of "idolaters" and "infidels" (e.g.,Q 2:191, 9:5, 9:73),
among other harsh commentary in the Koran as well as other texts such as the
hadiths.
While this 1.8 billion figure seems to be high for the present, according
to various predictions and
stated Islamist goals Islam will sweep the world, but, contrary to
the best wishes of some of its adherents, this invasion will not be peaceful.
It would be safe to say that few
non-Muslims would like to see this world taken over by Islam, which, along with
Christianity, represents the worst of Oriental despotism. Many futurists
and visionaries would like to see this world pry itself free of
religions, especially those stuck in the Dark Ages.
Indeed, to those who enjoy the ultimate
freedom of expression, these predictions and predations are chilling,
because Islam is a fervid theocracy with little room for individuality, not to
mention that it utterly denigrates the female aspect of creation.
The origins
of Islam
The
Muslim religion is obviously built upon the Judeo-Christian tradition, but
it is also a reaction to said tradition, which excluded and vilified the
various Arab cultures. Like their Jewish brothers and sisters, the Semitic
Arabs trace their lineage to the biblical patriarch Abraham, who is depicted in
the Bible as having mated with Hagar the Egyptian, producing the progenitor of
the Arab race, Ishmael.
While
the Jewish contingent interprets this tale to justify its own ethnocentric
ideology, Muslims interpret it to fit theirs, claiming that "God"
would make of Ishmael's people a "great nation" (Gen 21:18).
Typically, instead of searching for the truth about this tale, its proponents
have turned it into a political competition for global domination.
The Fictional Patriarch
Like numerous biblical characters, Abraham is
evidently a mythological construct, not a "real person."
As superb
independent scholar Barbara G. Walker states in The Woman's Encyclopedia of Myths and Secrets (5-6)
concerning Abraham:
"This name meaning 'Father Brahm' seems
to have been a Semitic version of India's patriarchal god Brahma; he was also
the Islamic Abrama, founder of Mecca. But Islamic legends say Abraham was a
late intruder into the shrine of the Kaaba. He bought it from priestesses of
its original Goddess.
Sarah, 'the Queen' was one of the Goddess's
titles, which became a name of Abraham's biblical 'wife.' Old Testament writers
pretended Sarah's alliances with Egyptian princes were only love-affairs
arranged by Abraham for his own profit—which unfortunately presented him as a
pimp (Genesis 12:16) as well as a would-be murderer of his son (Genesis 22:10).
"In the tale of Isaac's near-killing,
Abraham assumed the role of sacrificial priest in the druidic style, to wash
Jehovah's sacred trees with the Blood of the Son: an ancient custom, of which
the sacrifice of Jesus was only a late variant. Jehovah first appeared to
Abraham at the sacred oak of Shechem, where Abraham built his altar.
Later Abraham build an altar to the oak god
of Mamre at Hebron. Even in the 4th century A.D., Constantine said Abraham's
home at the Oak of Mamre was still a shrine: 'It is reported that most damnable
idols are set up beside it, and that an altar stands hard by, and that unclean
sacrifices are constantly
offered.'"
Allah—Remake of the Moon Goddess
This description of Abraham's origins
means that Judaism is built upon hoary myths, such that neither of
its offshoot religions, Christianity and Islam, can truthfully claim
to be of divine or "inspired" origin. As concerns the god of Islam,
Allah, Walker (22) has this to say:
"Late Islamic masculinization of the
Arabian Goddess, Al-Lat or Al-Ilat—the Allatu of the Babylonians—formerly
worshipped at the Kaaba in Mecca. It has been shown that 'the Allah of Islam'
was a male transformation of 'the primitive lunar deity of Arabia.' Her ancient
symbol the crescent moon still appears on Islamic flags, even though modern
Moslems no longer admit any feminine symbolism whatever connected with the
wholly patriarchal Allah."
Indeed, the Koran verifies Allah's lunar or
night-sky status: "Remember the name of our Lord morning and evening; in
the night-time worship Him: praise Him all night long." (Q 76:23) And at Q
2:189: "They question you about the phases of the moon. Say: 'They are
seasons fixed for mankind and for the pilgrimage.'"
In Pagan Rites in Judaism (97),
Theodor Reik states, in a chapter called "The ancient Semitic
moon-goddess":
"All Semites had once a cult of the moon
as supreme power. When Mohammed overthrew the old religion of Arabia, he did
not dare get rid of the moon cult in a radical manner. Only much later was he
powerful enough to forbid prostration before the moon (Koran Sure 4:37). Before
Islamic times the moon deity was the most prominent object of cults in ancient
Arabia. Arab women still insist that the moon is the parent of mankind.
"Sir G. Rawlinson traces the
name Chaldeans back to the designation of the ancient capital Ur
(Chur) to be translated as moon-worshipers. The Semitic moon-god was 'the
special deity and protector of women.' The Babylonians worshiped the goddess
Ishtar, who is identical with the great Arabian goddess and has the epithet Our
Lady... She also has the title Queen of Heaven, which really means
the Queen of the Stars. She was horned and was, as all lunar goddesses,
represented by a heavenly cow.
"The Hebrew tribes, or rather their
ancestors, were the latest wave of migrants from Arabia. The cult of their god
was associated with Mount Sinai—the mountain of the moon. The experts assume
that the name Sinai derived from Sin, the name of the Babylonian
moon-god. In Exodus (3:1) Sinai is called the 'mountain of the Elohim. This suggests that
it has long been sacred.'
"In the Old Testament, which is a
collection of much earlier, often edited writings, the moon appears as a power
of good (Deut. 33:4) or of evil (Ps. 12:16). Traces of ancient moon-worship
were energetically removed from the text by later editors. A few remained,
however, and can be recognized in the prohibitions of Deuteronomy. In 4:19 the
Israelites are warned: 'And lest thou lift up thine eyes upon heaven, and when
thou seest the sun, and the moon, and the stars, even all the host of heaven,
and be led astray to worship them, and serve them,' and in 17:3 the punishment
of stoning is prescribed for the person who 'hath gone and served other gods,
and worshipped them, either the sun, or moon, or any of the host of heaven...'
The Lord predicts (Jer.
8:2) that the bones of kings and princes of Judah will not be buried, but
spread 'before the sun, and the moon, and all the hosts of heaven, whom they
have loved, and whom they have served, and whom they have worshipped.'"
In The Origin of All Religious Worship (25-26),
concerning Arab astrotheology, which
was a continuation of this ancient Semitic lunar tradition, Charles Dupuis
states:
"The Moon was the great divinity of
the Arabs. The Sarazens gave her the epithet of Cabar or the Great; her
Crescent adorns to this day the religious monuments of the Turks. Her elevation
under the sign of the Bull, constituted one of the principal feasts of the
Saracens and the sabean Arabs. Each Arab tribe was under the invocation of a
constellation Each one worshipped one of the celestial bodies as its tutelar
genius.
"The Caabah of the Arabs was before the
time of Mahomet, a temple dedicated to the Moon. The black stone which the
Musulmans kiss with so much devotion to this day, is, as it is pretended, an
ancient statue of Saturnus. The walls of the great mosque of Kufah, built on the
foundation of an ancient Pyrea or temple of the fire, are filled with figures
of planets artistically engraved. The ancient worship of the Arabs was the
Sabismus, a religion universally spread all over the Orient. Heaven and the
Stars were the first objects thereof.
"This religion was that of the ancient
Chaldeans, and the Orientals pretend that their Ibrahim or Abraham was brought
up in that doctrine. There is still to be seen at Hella, over the ruins of the
ancient Babylon, a mosque called Mesched Eschams, or the mosque of the Sun. It
was in this city, that the ancient temple of Bel, or the Sun, the great
Divinity of the Babylonians, existed; it is the same God, to whom the Persians
erected temples and consecrated images under the name of Mithras."
Women Oppression and Cultural Bigotry
This repression of the female is sadly
ironic when one considers the roots of Islam, but it is not unexpected in a
world that, for the past several thousand
years, has done everything within its power to subjugate women simply because
of physical differences, a male-domination need shared with the apes and other
"lesser beasts."
While some may claim that this subjugation
and enslavement of women is a cultural tradition, rather than a religious one,
it matters not, for it comes hand-in-hand with religions which teach that there
is some separate outer space god
who is exclusively male.
In Islam, this god is interpreted through the
minds of Muslims as being an Arab or Persian man, as opposed to the Jewish man
of the Judeo-Christian ideology. This racist, ethnocentric, culturally bigoted
and sexist interpretation of any "infinite" god would appear to
be absolute nonsense.
Yet, in what seems to be supreme arrogance and
megalomania, many individuals would like the entire world to believe it is
true.
Astrotheology at Mecca
One of the sites for this Arab worship of the
"hosts of heaven" was Mecca. Regarding the Kaaba of Mecca, that
holiest of Muslim holies, Walker (487) writes:
"Shrine of the sacred stone in Mecca,
formerly dedicated to the pre-Islamic Triple Goddess Manat, Al-Lat (Allah), and
Al-Uzza, the 'Old Woman' worshipped by Mohammed's tribesmen the Koreshites.
The stone was also called Kubaba, Kuba or
Kube, and has been linked with the name of Cybele (Kybela), the Great Mother of
the Gods. The stone bore the emblem of theyoni, like the Black
Stone worshipped by votaries of Artemis. Now it is regarded as the holy center
of patriarchal Islam, and its feminine symbolism has been lost, though priests
of the Kaaba are still known as Sons of the Old Woman."
And a translator of the Koran, N.J. Dawood
(1), says:
"Long before Muhammad's call, Arabian
paganism was showing signs of decay. At the Ka'bah the Meccans worshipped not
only Allah, the supreme Semitic God, but also a number of female deities whom
they regarded as daughters of Allah. Among these were Al-Lat, Al-Uzza and
Manat, who represented the Sun, Venus and Fortune respectively."
Arabian Matriarchy
Concerning the nation of Arabia, Walker
asserts that, prior to the encroachment of Islam, it was a matriarchal culture
for over 1,000 years:
"The Annals of Ashurbanipal said Arabia
was governed by queens for as long as anyone could remember....
"Mohammed's legends clearly gave him a
matriarchal family background. His parents' marriage was matrilocal. His mother
remained with her own family and received her husband as an occasional
visitor....
"Pre-Islamic Arabia was dominated by the
female-centered clans. Marriages were matrilocal, inheritance matrilineal.
Polyandry—several husbands to one wife—was common. Men lived in their wives'
homes. Divorce was initiated by the wife. If she turned her tent to face east
for three nights in a row, the husband was dismissed and forbidden to enter the
tent again.
"Doctrines attributed to Mohammed simply
re-versed the ancient system in favor of men. A Moslem husband could dismiss
his wife by saying 'I divorce thee' three times. As in Europe, the change from
matriarchate to patriarchate came about only gradually and with much strife.
"...However, the history of
early-medieval Arabia is nearly all legend. Like Buddha, Confucius, Jesus and
other founders of patriarchal religions, Mohammed lacks real
verification. There is no reliable information about his life or
teachings. Most stories about him are as apocryphal as the story that his
coffin hangs forever in mid-air 'between heaven and earth,' like the bodies of
ancient sacred kings.
"With or without Mohammed, Islam
succeeded in becoming completely male-dominated, making no place for women
except in slavery or in the seclusion of the harem. Islamic mosques still bear
signs reading: 'Women and dogs and other impure animals are not permitted to enter.'
"Nevertheless, traces of the Goddess proved
ineradicable. Like the virgin Mary, Arabia's Queen of Heaven received a
mortal form and a subordinate position as Fatima, Mohammed's 'daughter.' But
she was no real daughter. She was known as Mother of her Father, and Source of
the Sun..."
Who Wrote the
Koran
As concerns the Koran, the Muslim holy
book, Walker (513) says:
"Mohammedan scriptures, often
erroneously thought to have been written by Mohammed. Moslems don't believe
this. But many don't know the Koran was an enlarged revised version of the
ancient Word of the Goddess Kore, revered by Mohammed's tribe, the Koreshites
(Children of Kore), who guarded her shrine at Mecca.
"The original writing was done long
before Mohammed's time by holy imams, a word related to Semitic ima,
'mother.'
Like the original mahatmas or
'great mothers' of India, the original imams were probably
priestesses of the old Arabian matriarchate. It was said they took the
scripture from a prototype that existed in heaven from the beginning ofeternity,
'Mother of the Book'—i.e., the Goddess herself, wearing the Book of Fate on her
breast as Mother Tiamat wore the Tablets of Destiny.
Sometimes the celestial Koran was called the
Preserved Tablet. There was some resemblance between this and other legendary
books of divine origin, such as the Ur-text, the Book of Thoth, and the Emerald
Tablet of Hermes.
"As in the case of the Judeo-Christian
Bible, the Koran was much rewritten to support new patriarchal laws and to
obliterate the figures of the Goddess and her priestesses."
In The Great Religious Leaders, Charles
Frances Potter says of Mohammed, "It is very doubtful that he read any of
the Bible: indeed, it has not been proved that he ever read anything, or wrote
anything. He called himself 'the illiterate prophet.'" Of course,
much of the Koran is based on the Bible, both Old and New Testaments, combined
with pre-Islamic Arab and other traditions.
Regarding the unoriginality of the Koran,
Islam expert Dr. Daniel Pipes says (The Jerusalem Post, 5/12/00):
"The Koran is a not 'a product of
Muhammad or even of Arabia,' but a collection of earlier Judeo-Christian
liturgical materials stitched together to meet the needs of a later
age."
Biblical scholar Dr. Robert M. Price likewise
concurs as to the pre-Islamic nature of various koranic texts:
"The Koran was assembled from a variety
of prior Hagarene texts (hence the contradictions re Jesus' death) in
order to provide the Moses-like Muhammad with a Torah of his own...."
Islamic expert Dr. Gerd-R. Puin concludes:
"My idea is that the Koran is a kind of
cocktail of texts that were not all understood even at the time of Muhammad.
Many of them may even be a hundred years older than Islam itself. Even within
Islamic traditions there is a huge body of contradictory information, including
a significant Christian substrate...."
Thus, the Koran was not written
by Mohammed.
The Yemeni Koran
Adding significantly to this important
scholarship was the discovery in 1972 at Sana'a, Yemen, of thousands of
parchment fragments from the Koran, consisting of possibly the oldest extant
quranic manuscript ever found, dating to the 7th-8th centuries.
Regarding these fragments, the professor who
photographed them, Dr. Puin, remarks:
"So many Muslims have this belief that
everything between the two covers of the Koran is just God’s unaltered word.
They like to quote the textual work that
shows the Bible has a history and did not fall straight out of the sky, but
until now the Koran has been out of this discussion. The only way to break
through this wall is to prove that the Koran has a history too. The Sana’a
fragments will help us do that."
Concerning the texts and Puin's conclusions, The
Atlantic Monthly's Toby Lester states:
"...some of these fragments revealed
small but intriguing aberrations from the stand Koranic text. Such aberrations,
though not surprising to textual historians, are troublingly at odds with the
orthodox Muslim belief that the Koran as it has reached us today is quite
simply the perfect, timeless, and unchanging Word of God.... What the Yemeni
Korans seems to suggest,
Puin began to feel, was an evolving text rather than simply the Word of God as
revealed in its entirety to the Prophet Muhammad in the seventh century
A.D."
Others weighing in on the value of the
Yemeni discovery have included Dr. Andrew Rippin, a professor of Islamic
Studies:
"The impact of the Yemeni manuscripts is
still to be felt. Their variant readings and verse orders are all very
significant. Everybody agrees on that. These manuscripts say that the early
history of the Koranic texts is much more of an open question than many have
suspected: the text was less stable, and therefore had less authority, than has
always been claimed."
In this same regard, Islamic history
professor Dr. R. Stephen Humphreys summarizes the importance of the study of
how the Koran was created and the Yemeni hoard in this quest:
"To historicize the Koran would in
effect delegitimize the whole historical experience of the Muslim community.
The Koran is the charter for the community, the document that called it into
existence.
And ideally though obviously not always in reality Islamic history
has been the effort to pursue and work out
the commandments of the Koran in human life. If the Koran is a historical
document, then the whole Islamic struggle of fourteen centuries is effectively
meaningless."
The evidence reveals that the Koran was
created over a period of decades, if not centuries, by a number of hands,
rather than representing a
single, divine "revelation" from the Almighty to
Mohammed.
Who Was Mohammed
Like that of Buddha, Jesus, Moses, et al., Mohammed's
historicity is questionable. He seems to be yet
another religious figurehead invented to create a "state"
religion. His "history" is full of fantastic legends, but even if we
were to find a "historical person" there, it would not be one of very
high or affable character. As Potter says:
"Of women, his taste ran to widows with
a temper... For recreation he delighted in cobbling shoes. Perhaps his greatest
joy was when he beheld the severed heads of his enemies.
"His dislikes were just as varied. He
detested silk-lined clothes, interest charges, dogs, others' lies, Jews and
Christians. He hated poets, and said, 'Every painter will be in hell.'
"He was inordinately vain. A clever woman poet
satirized him. She was slain when asleep with her child at her breast, and the
vengeful Muhammad praised her murderer. Once he tortured a Jew to find the
location of hidden treasure and then had him killed and added the widow to his
harem. Strange indeed was the character of the prophet. How could such a person
inspire such reverence and devotion? It is one of the puzzles of history.
"It was not that he developed a great
theology, either, for what little theology Islam has, worthy of the name, was
built up after Muhammad had long been dead."
According to the hadiths or hadees—records of the
purported sayings and acts of Mohammed and his companions—the Prophet was indeed of a
character that would repulse any decent human being.
One after another of the hadiths discuss Mohammed's insatiable sexual
appetite, which included having sex with his "wife" 'Aisha, who was 9 years old and had
not even reached puberty. Various Islamic authorities have also claimed that Mohammed began
"thighing" 'Aisha when he married her at the age of six.
As to how such a character could inspire such
reverence and devotion, we would submit that it was because Mohammed and Islam
were created by yet another faction of "the brotherhood" for purposes
of competition withJudaism, Christianity,
Zoroastrianism and other religions. As N.A Morozov says:
"...until the Crusades Islam was
indistinguishable from Judaism and...only then did it receive its
independent character, while Muhammad and the
first Caliphs are mythical figures."
Behind the creation of such ideologies are
usually those who benefit the most, particularly "third-party"
weapons manufacturers, since these divisive creeds are forever setting one
culture against another.
Despite the unconvincing attempts by
well-meaning individuals to assert the pacificism of Islam, the fact is that it
is a desert warrior's religion and was not spread by peaceful means. As Gerald
Berry says, in Religions of the World (62):
"Partly because he needed funds and
partly because his followers were not skilled in agriculture as were the
natives of Yathrib, [Mohammed] organized fighting bands to raid caravans.
Having no ties with the older religions, he sent them out even in the peace
months. This started Arabia's Holy War. Mohammed's whole movement took on the
character of religious militarism. He made the Moslem fanatic fighters by
teaching that admission to Paradise was assured for all those who died fighting
in the cause of Allah."
In the end, Islam, which means
"submission," is built upon older myths and traditions and was
designed to usurp the power of Christians, Jews and women. While we have no
quarrel with all Arabian culture, we do have a big problem with ideologies that
are filled with half-truths and lies.
Because of arrogance and bigotry,
ancient cultures, along with their variety, justice and beauty, have become
nearly obliterated. In effect, the Western monolithic religions represent a
massive degradation of culture.
If this world’s inhabitants would simply become educated to
the origins of their traditions in full, we could live in a world of tremendous
beauty and knowledge, as opposed to ugly, superstitious and repressive
ideologies that are exclusionary and bigoted.
Islam arose because of the repression of
Christianity and Judaism, as well as an unbalanced female-oriented
culture. Like those traditions, Islam is utterly out of balance, and we may all
suffer for it, particularly if the predictions come true that Islam will be the
most dominant religion in the world in the next decades.
As previously stated, there are few
non-Muslim women or men who would wish to live in such a world. Because of this
aversion, we would expect to see in the future innumerable ghastly battles and
wars waged in the name of one god or another, as has happened far too often in
the past, especially with these monotheistic Abrahamic faiths of Judaism,
Christianity and Islam.
All told, these three are responsible for the
deaths of hundreds of millions of people, so why are they deemed "Great religions?"
The "greatest" thing about them is their death toll.
If this world is to survive into the coming age, we will need as many people as possible to drop all of these divisive doctrines. What we need in the world right now, are honest, caring and whole human beings who are motivated not by potential favors and rewards from sadistic and ethnocentric deities in the sky, but by innate decency and integrity.
Only in this way can we all live in peace
rather than fear, which is the weapon wielded by religion to convert the
"faithful."
Sources & Further Reading
Berry, Gerald. Religions of the Word.
Barnes & Noble, 1955.
Dawood, N.J. The Koran. London: Penguin Books, 1995.
Dupuis, Charles. The Origins of All Religious Worship.
Glazov, Jamie. "The Yemeni Koran." FrontpageMag.com
Potter, Charles Francis. The Great Religious Leaders. New York: Simon & Schuster, 1958.
Reik, Theodor. Pagan Rites in Judaism. New York: Farrar, Strauss, 1964.
Walker, Barbara G. The Woman’s Encyclopedia of Myths and Secrets. HarperSanFrancisco, 1983.
Dawood, N.J. The Koran. London: Penguin Books, 1995.
Dupuis, Charles. The Origins of All Religious Worship.
Glazov, Jamie. "The Yemeni Koran." FrontpageMag.com
Potter, Charles Francis. The Great Religious Leaders. New York: Simon & Schuster, 1958.
Reik, Theodor. Pagan Rites in Judaism. New York: Farrar, Strauss, 1964.
Walker, Barbara G. The Woman’s Encyclopedia of Myths and Secrets. HarperSanFrancisco, 1983.